I love this affordable Nutrogena oil free eye makeup remover. It works wonderfully, even on the smokey eye nights. It’s so silky and slimy (in a good way), I don’t understand how it’s oil free. I also don’t care! I care that it leaves very little residue on my face and  works fast. No eyelash loss, and no need to wash your face again just to remove the remover. The liquids separate in the bottle ( like an oil and water thing) so make sure you shake it before you use.