well, my lashes have. I have the good problem of having very long lashes. This is a problem because they touch my brow bone and under eye area. The undereye is the bigger problem since I don’t want any dark color there. I thought I’d give tubing mascara a go, and I thought I’d go for a cheap brand that never lets me down. Essence’s Bye Bye Panda Eyes does the trick! It’s only $4.99 at Ulta. A few quick swipes on my lashes and they are good to go with zero smudge. It comes off easy with my regular nighttime cleanser.